What is a Segregated Account? Are customer funds really safer?

---

Almost every broker's account opening page features a phrase like "Client funds are held in segregated accounts" next to a shield icon. This statement sounds reassuring, but rarely does it explain what the funds are segregated from, under which legal authority, or how those funds would be returned to depositors if the company were to actually fail.

This article explains the mechanics of a Segregated Account layer by layer, covering what it truly protects, what it never protects, and how to verify if the claims on a website are genuinely backed.

What is a Segregated Account?

A Segregated Account is a bank account used by a broker to hold client funds separately from the company's own operational accounts. Funds in this account legally remain the property of the client; the company holds them only as a custodian. Therefore, these funds cannot be used to pay salaries, marketing expenses, or the company's debts.

The terms used in actual regulatory documents are often not "segregated account" directly, but rather "client money" or "trust account," which convey a clearer meaning: these funds are held in trust, with the holder acting as a custodian, not the owner.

Where Does a Trader's Money Go After Transfer?

Most depositors only see two points: the amount disappearing from their own bank account and the amount appearing on the trading platform. Between these two points, there are several layers of steps.

First, the money leaves the depositor's bank account and goes to the payment recipient used by the broker, which could be a direct bank, a card payment provider, or an international money transfer intermediary. This is where the risk begins, because if the money is instructed to be transferred to an individual's account or a company account that does not match the licensed legal entity, client money protection never even starts from the first step.

Second, the money enters the client account opened by the broker with a bank. Top-tier regulatory rules set a relatively narrow timeframe. For example, the Financial Conduct Authority's handbook under CASS 7.13 Segregation of client money stipulates that firms must place client money into a client account at the latest by the close of the next business day after receiving it.

Third, the balance on the trading platform is updated, and this is where most people misunderstand. The number seen on the screen is merely an accounting entry indicating how much the company owes the depositor, not the actual money sitting in the depositor's own account. The security of that balance therefore depends on where the real money backing that number is held, not on how aesthetically pleasing the platform display is.

Finally, when an order is opened, a portion of the balance is set aside as collateral. This portion remains in the client account but is locked until the position is closed. The mechanism for setting aside these funds and what happens when collateral is insufficient is explained in the article What is a Margin Call and When Does it Occur?

How Do Segregated Accounts Differ from Company Operational Accounts?

The difference is not in the account name or the bank used, but in the legal status of those funds.

The most crucial line in the table is the one about creditors. That is the entire reason this mechanism exists. If depositor funds are commingled with company funds, when the company incurs debt, depositors would be no different from suppliers waiting in line for repayment, and that line is often longer than the remaining assets.

Pooled Accounts vs. Individual Accounts: Common Misconceptions

The term "segregated account" leads many to imagine a bank account with their own name on it. In the practical reality of the retail market, this scenario almost never occurs.

Almost all actual implementations use a pooled account, also known as an omnibus account. All client funds are held in a single account, separate from company funds, but not separate from each other. What determines who owns how much is the company's internal accounting system, which must reconcile with the actual funds in the bank according to regulatory cycles.

This model has two practical implications you should be aware of:

First, if the internal accounting system makes an error, or if funds are misappropriated before the company fails, the total balance in the bank account will be less than the total amount the company owes its clients. This difference is called a shortfall, and when it occurs, all clients will receive a proportional refund of the missing amount equally; it's not a case of "first in, first out".

Second, holding funds in a pooled account makes the refund process time-consuming. The liquidator must verify the entitlements of all accounts before disbursement. In many real-world cases, this process takes years, not weeks.

Truly individual segregated accounts do exist, but they are typically reserved for institutional clients or large clients who negotiate terms on a case-by-case basis, not something generally offered to retail accounts.

Client Money Segregation Rules Vary by Regulator

The point that makes the advertising claim "has a segregated account" almost meaningless is that this term is not tied to a uniform global standard. The level of regulation, oversight, and what happens when a company fails varies significantly depending on the jurisdiction that issues the license.

The difference this table attempts to highlight is between "segregated because legally mandated and audited" and "segregated because the company says so." These two can be written on a website using the same sentence, but they yield entirely different outcomes when the company faces problems.

Another point to be aware of is when affiliated companies hold multiple licenses in various countries and then allow applicants from certain regions to open accounts with an offshore-registered entity, rather than an entity under a top-tier regulator. The advertising may point to the most reputable license, but the actual contract signed by the depositor is tied to a different legal entity. The mechanism for verifying which legal entity you are opening an account with is explained in the article How to Check if a Forex Broker is Trustworthy: 7 Steps Before Depositing Funds

What Segregated Accounts Protect and Don't Protect

This mechanism is designed to solve one specific problem: preventing client funds from being commingled with company funds to the point of being indistinguishable when the company faces financial difficulties. Everything outside that scope is not protected.

The first row on the right is the one most often misunderstood. Account segregation does not make a portfolio safer by even a single baht from price movements. Funds lost due to losing orders are considered to have legitimately left the client account according to the contract, and no mechanism can reclaim them. The effect of high leverage on the speed at which capital disappears is explained in the article What is Forex Leverage and How Risky is it?

Similarly, costs deducted from the balance each time an order is opened and closed are entirely outside this scope. Details of those costs are in the article What is Spread and How Does it Differ from Commission?

Investor Compensation Funds are a Separate Layer from Account Segregation

These two mechanisms are often discussed interchangeably, leading to the misconception that they are the same, even though they operate at different stages.

Account segregation works first; its role is to keep funds intact and identifiable by owner. Compensation funds work later, when the segregated funds are insufficient for full repayment, such as in cases of shortfall due to fraud or accounting errors.

In the United Kingdom, the latter mechanism is the Financial Services Compensation Scheme, which covers investment claims up to £85,000 per person per firm for companies that fail after April 1, 2019, as stated on the FSCS investment protection page.

In Cyprus, the equivalent mechanism is the Investor Compensation Fund, which pays a maximum of €20,000, calculated as the lower of 90 percent of the covered claim amount or the €20,000 ceiling. Details are in the CySEC Investor Guide to the Investor Compensation Fund.

Both figures are ceilings, not automatically paid amounts, and do not cover market losses in all cases. Those who deposit more than the ceiling therefore have an excess amount that no mechanism supports, beyond the actual funds that were successfully segregated.

How to Self-Verify if a Broker Truly Segregates Client Funds

Statements on an advertising page are not proof. There are five verifiable points:

Point 1: Find the actual legal entity you are contracting with. Open the terms of service document and check the company name and country of registration on the first or last page. Compare it with the name appearing on the advertising page. If they don't match, the protection claimed might not be the protection you will receive.

Point 2: Search the regulator's registry using that legal entity's name, not the brand name. The registry will specify the scope of authorized activities, which indicates whether client money rules are binding on this company.

Point 3: Read the client money section in the contract. Look for wording that states funds are held in trust, specifies the type of depository bank, and outlines reconciliation cycles. A contract that merely states "the company will segregate client funds according to internal policy" without citing any specific regulation is worth less than you might think.

Point 4: Look for disclaimers that revoke protection. The wording to read carefully is the title transfer collateral arrangement. This clause changes the status of funds from client money to company assets, in exchange for a contractual claim. In many jurisdictions, this clause is prohibited for retail clients, but it can still be found in contracts of offshore entities.

Point 5: Test the money's path before making a large deposit. Check if the transfer destination is an account in the name of the licensed legal entity. If the destination is an individual's account, an unrelated company's account, or a channel that leaves no verifiable trace, the advertised account segregation has no effect on those funds from the outset.

These five points combined take less than an hour and can be done before transferring the first baht.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Please Note: Forex trading is not yet licensed or regulated by any authority in Thailand. The Bank of Thailand does not have a policy to issue licenses for Forex business to retail individuals (Reference: Thai PBS), and the SEC (Securities and Exchange Commission) itself confirms that the Forex business is not under the SEC's supervision but rather under the foreign exchange control law (Reference: The Standard).

This article is provided for general knowledge only, not as personal investment advice, and offers no guarantees of returns. Traders should conduct further research and assess risks independently before making any decisions.

Does a segregated account make funds 100% safe?

No. This mechanism solves only one problem: separating client funds from the pool of assets that company creditors have a right to claim. However, it does not protect against market losses, trading costs, delays in the refund process, or shortfalls that occur before the company fails.

If a broker goes bankrupt, will I get my full money back?

It depends on whether the funds in the client account fully match the total amount the company owes its clients. If they are complete and the process proceeds normally, the chances of full recovery are high. If a shortfall occurs, all clients will receive a proportional refund equally, and the missing portion would then rely on the compensation fund of that jurisdiction, which has a ceiling and is not available in all jurisdictions.

How can I tell if a broker truly segregates accounts, and isn't just claiming it on their website?

Check the contractual documents and the regulator's registry, not just the advertising page. The "How to Verify" section above outlines five points, from finding the actual legal entity you are contracting with to checking the destination of your fund transfers.

Can I trust a broker that doesn't have a top-tier license but claims to have a segregated account?

Such claims cannot be externally verified. Without mandatory reconciliation and reporting, and without specific client money audits, account segregation is merely a promise in the service agreement, which is difficult to enforce in practice when the company stops responding.

Do segregated accounts earn interest?

Generally, interest generated from client accounts must be clearly specified in the contract. Some jurisdictions have specific rules for handling this interest. Depositors should read the client money section of the contract to see which party is entitled to the interest, rather than making assumptions.

References

• FCA Handbook, CASS 7.13 Segregation of client money
• ASIC, Regulatory Guide 212 Client money relating to dealing in OTC derivatives (PDF)
• ASIC, Complying with the ASIC Client Money Reporting Rules 2017
• CySEC, Investor Guide to the Investor Compensation Fund
• FSCS, Investment compensation and protection
• Thai PBS, BOT Confirms No Policy to License Forex Business
• The Standard, SEC Confirms Forex Business Not Under Its Supervision